78. Il Guarany (Gomes)


  • Opera-ballo in 4 acts
  • Composer: Antônio Carlos Gomes
  • Libretto: Antonio Scalvini
  • First performed: Teatro alla Scala, Milan, 19 March 1870

Don ANTONIO DE MARIZ, old Portuguese hidalgoBassTeodoro Coloni
CECILIA, his daughterSopranoMarie Sass
PERY, chief of the Guarany tribeTenorGiuseppe Villani
Don ALVARO, Portuguese adventurerTenorGiuseppe Masato
GONZALES, Spanish adventurer, Don Antonio’s guestBaritoneEnrico Storti
RUY-BENTO, idem.TenorAnnubale Micheloni
ALONSO, idem.BassSeverino Mazza
IL CACICO, chief of the Aimorè tribeBass / baritoneVictor Maurel
PEDRO, Don Antonio’s man-at-armsBass 
Adventurers from different countries – Men and women of the Portuguese colony – Aimorè tribeChorus; ballet 

SETTING: Brazil, near Rio de Janeiro – 1560

Rating: 3 out of 5.

A Brazilian composer of mixed African, Portuguese, and Amerindian blood, Carlos Gomes was the first Latin American and non-European composer to make it big.

After making his name in Brazil with a couple of Portuguese-language, Italian-style operas, Emperor Dom Pedro II gave Gomes a scholarship to study in Milan.

Gomes’ first Italian work was Il Guarany, an opera-ballo (Italian version of French grand opera, with exotic setting, historical subject, choruses, and dancing).

It was his biggest success at La Scala, and a hit throughout Europe, performed almost everywhere except France, Germany, and Austria.

“This young man begins where I finish,” Verdi remarked; the opera was “true musical genius”.  Liszt said that “it displays dense technical maturity, full of harmonic and orchestral maturity.”

The Milan premiere came three weeks after the Brazilians defeated Solano López in Paraguay.  “To Brazilians, Il Guarany recalled Verdi’s popular midcentury operas, stemming from the Italian risorgimento, which were loaded with ideas of unification, and moments of patriotic display.”  The opera was “a trademark of Brazilianness”.

“Gomes was the first Brazilian to achieve the status of an international composer, elevating Brazil to the status of ‘civilised’ nation.”  (Carmen Nava & Ludwig Lauerhass, eds., Brazil in the Making: Facets of National Identity, 2006.)

More operas followed: Fosca (1873), which audiences found too gloomy and WagnerianSalvator Rosa (1874), a successful historical work about the Neapolitan revolution (the same subject as Auber‘s Muette de Portici); and Maria Tudor (1879), with a libretto by Arrigo Boito.  The Brazilians consider Lo schiavo (1889), calling for the abolition of slavery, Gomes’ masterpiece.  The failure of Condor (1891) forced Gomes to leave Italy and return to Brazil.

Gomes the man is more interesting than his music.  Il Guarany is a mixture of the good and the conventional, even banal.

Gomes’ talent seems to lie in ensembles, such as the Ave Maria (I), the Coro di Aimorè (III), and the Congiura (IV).  Also striking is the Cacico’s invocation at the end of III.  It would, I imagine, be exciting on stage; the cavalry – I mean, the Portuguese troops – arrive just as Pery is about to be sacrificed.

Otherwise, the score is full of standard operatic gestures.  Cecilia’s inane entrance aria is the sort of thing Bellini and Donizetti were writing 40 years before; she appears singing, of all things to sing in 16th century Brazil, a polacca!  The cannibal tribe later dances a mazurka.  The Act III trio is of Meyerbeerian cut, particularly the phrase “Or bene insano”, while situations recall L’Africaine (Marie Sasse, who first sang Sélika, also created Cecilia) and Le Prophète (explosive ending).


The opera is based on the novel O Guarani (1857), by the Brazilian writer José de Alencar.  Guarany and Aimoré are the names of the two principal tribes of Indians.  Pery was the chief of the Guarany; and the chief of the Aimoré is simply called “Cacico” (chief).

ACT I: Outside Don Antonio’s castle

The Aimorè Indians have sworn to avenge one of their women, accidentally killed by a Portuguese.  Don Antonio expects the Indians to attack.  Pery, chief of the Guarany tribe, promises to help the Europeans; he loves Don Antonio’s daughter Cecilia, whose life he saved.  So does the Spanish adventurer Gonzales.  But Don Antonio wants Cecilia to marry the Portuguese Don Alvaro.

Pery discovers that the Spaniards are plotting against the Portuguese.

Twilight falls, and the evening bell summons the Europeans to prayer.

Alone, Pery and Cecilia declare their love.


A grotto in the jungle

Gonzales and the Spanish adventurers are plotting to capture a secret mine, and kidnap Cecilia.  Pery, who has overheard the conversation, confronts Gonzales, and spares his life if he leaves the country.

The adventurers’ camp

The adventurers plot to attack that night, and sing a song in praise of gold and adventure.

Cecilia’s room

Cecilia, alone in her room, sings a ballad while thinking of the young and handsome Pery.

Gonzales steals into her room, and tries to rape Cecilia.  Pery wounds him with an arrow, and denounces him before all.  The Aimorè attack the castle.


The camp of the Aimorè tribe

The Aimorè have captured Cecilia.

The Cacico, leader of the tribe, is struck by her beauty, and wants to make her his queen.  The Indians bring in Pery, who confesses to entering the camp to kill the chief and rescue Cecilia.  He will be eaten by the tribal elders, after a night of love with Cecilia.  The Portuguese rescue the couple; Don Alvaro is killed.


The castle vaults

Gonzales and his comrades, now allied with the Aimorè, plot to murder Don Antonio – but he discovers their conspiracy.  He baptises Pery, who escapes with Cecilia.  When Gonzales and his men arrive, Don Antonio blows them all up.


I investigated four recordings, none fully satisfying.

Manrico Patassini (Pery) and Niza de Castro Tank (Cecilia), with the Orquestra Sinfônica de São Paulo, conducted by Armando Belardi.  São Paulo, 1959.

More passion and life than the Domingo, but many cuts.

Plácido Domingo (Pery) and Veronica Villaroel (Cecilia), with the Beethovenhalle Bonn, conducted by John Neschling.  Bonn.

Best sound, and a star singer, but rather dull.

I gave up after Act I.  Inadequate tenor; static production; impossible translations.  (“Caccia” and “Cacico” surely don’t mean “caca”!)




Outside Don Antonio’s castle

  • Coro di Cacciatori: Scorre il cacciator
  • Dialogo, Scena e Sortita Pery – Pery
  • Polacca – Sortita Cecilia – Gentile di cuore – Cecilia
  • Ave Maria
  • Seguito e Stretta – Venga pur l’iniqua schiera
  • Scena e Duetto – Sento una forza indomita – Cecilia & Pery


A grotto in the jungle

  • Scena ed Aria – Vanto io pur superba cuna – Pery
  • Scena e Duetto – Serpe vil – Pery & Gonzales

The adventurers’ camp

  • Coro di Avventurieri – L’oro è un ente si gioconde
  • Canzone dell’Avventurieri – Senza tetto, senza cuna – Gonzales

Cecilia’s room

  • Ballata – C’era una volta un principe – Cecilia
  • Scena e Duetto – Donna, tu forse l’unica – Cecilia & Gonzales
  • Pezzo concertato Finale secondo – Vedi quel volto livido
  • Seguito e Chiusa del Finale secondo – Vile indiano, trema! trema!


The camp of the Aimorè tribe

  • Coro di Aimorè – Aspra, crudel, terribile
  • Scena e Duettino – Giovinetta, nello sguardo – Cecilia & Cacico
  • Coro e Terzetto – Or bene, insano – Cecilia, Pery & Cacico
  • Introduzione, Ballabili e Azione mimica
  • Gran Marcia – Baccanale indiano
  • Scena – Il passo estremo
  • Gran Scena e Duetto – Perchè di meste lagrime – Cecilia & Pery
  • Invocazione – O Dio degli Aimorè – Il Cacico
  • Scena-Finale terzo


The castle vaults

  • Coro, Scena e Congiura – In quest’ora suprema – Gonzales
  • Scena del Battesimo – Sul cupo torrente – Pery & Don Antonio
  • Gran Scena e Terzetto finale ultimo – Con te giurai di vivere – Cecilia, Pery & Don Antonio

12 thoughts on “78. Il Guarany (Gomes)

  1. Thanks so much for your video/music/information. I ran into this Opera because my figure skating Pro cut the Overture for me as a competitive program. I enjoyed the music, and felt it. Later on, I tried to find the Opera in performance. I have seen it twice, and like it. Your additional material was very welcome. I think it is something that should be done more often, & appreciated.. Over time, I have become a great Opera fan. and there are some terrific works on the fringe of repertoire.


    1. Thanks, Mark! It’s a majestic overture. I’d like to listen to more Gomes, but not many have English translations. What are some of your other favourite works on the fringe of the repertoire?


      1. You asked me about other favorite operas on the fringe of the repertoire, here are some (possibly misspelled): Rossini Armida; Monteverdi Ritorno d’Ulisse en Patria; Lully Atys; Weber Euryanthe; Massenet Esclaremonde, Griselidis; Nielsen Saul & David; Tchaikovsky Cherevitchki; Rimsky- Korsakov Tale of Tsar Saltan, Tsar’s Bride; Moore Ballad of Baby Doe; Lalo Le Roi d’Y’s; Gounod Mireille; Moniuszko Halka, Haunted Manor; Marshner Hans Heiling, Der Vampyr.


      2. Moniuszko! Have you heard Straszny dwór? It’s wonderful.

        I’m also a big fan of the Massenets.

        I’ve written about Armida, Ritorno d’Ulisse, Atys (my first Lully – I didn’t like it), Euryanthe, and Le Roi d’Ys.


      3. I love Moniuszko! I have seen Halka, Haunted Manor, Verum Nobile a couple of times. I watched one on Operavision called Jawnuta.. and another one I don’t remember how to spell (something like Parisi). The one that I haven’t run into is The Countess.


      4. You said you did not care for Lully’s Atys. Have you seen the William Christie version with Stephanie d’Oustrac? I don’t always like her, but she is very moving in this, I think. My tastes seem to be moving towards Baroque Opera. Another Opera I have never seen, but would like to, is Britten’s Midsummere Night’s Dream.


      5. I’ve watched the Christie Atys. I much prefer Rousset, Niquet, and Minkowski in Baroque music.

        A Midsummer Night’s Dream is magical. I saw Opera Australia’s 2010 production, directed by Baz Luhrmann:


      6. Just watched the YouTube Hrabina you suggested. Good music, lots of dancing, great orchestration, but sort of a strange structure. The denouement comes really suddenly.. the betrothed couple at the end have spent almost no time together, and don’t even get a love duet. At times, it feels like a comedy with a moral.. sometimes it feels almost like an Operetta; but, at the end, the Countess is obviously in real pain. Is this an Opera that has dialogue that they cut? Anyway, glad to have seen it. The clip of Midsummer Night’s Dream looked really good. I wonder if the DVD’s for sale on Arkivmusic? Have you ever heard Weber’s Oberon? I only have heard like a “highlights” CD.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.